top of page
Legacy FLAVORS
These cookies are a slight twist on a delicious classic favorite. Made with organic peanut butter, they are filled with a rich organic peanut butter and Belgian white chocolate filling, then sprinkled with finely chopped peanuts. Soft and tender, each bite delivers the
perfect balance of sweet and salty peanut flavor.
This classic cookie favorite gets an elevated twist. Crafted with golden brown butter, with each bite offering a rich, nutty flavor perfectly balanced with just the right touch of sweetness and topped with sea salt flakes.
Crisp edges lead to soft, chewy centers filled with premium
Beligan chocolate.
It’s a nostalgic treat with a gourmet upgrade."
If you're a fan of Butter Pecan ice cream, these cookies are sure to win you over. They're rich, chewy, and packed with roasted pecans, all brought together with a hint of our homemade butter toffee.
Buttery, nutty, and irresistibly satisfying in every bite.
Crafted with a warm blend of hearty organic oats, plump organic sun-dried raisins, and a robust flavor of Ceylon cinnamon, these Oatmeal Raisin Cookies bring comfort with a touch of elegance. Lightly crisp edges and a soft chewy center create the perfect texture—another elevated classic cookie.
The Original. The cookie that started it all.
This is the signature cookie recipe that launched Nicky’s Cookies.
A sophisticated blend of creamy Belgian white chocolate, sweetened
dried cranberries, and a sprinkle of toasted almonds. The secret?
A touch of coconut that you won’t detect—but your taste buds will.
One bite, and it’s easy to see why this cookie keeps people coming
back for more.
"The Harriet"
Triple Chocolate Decadence
Bold. Audacious. This cookie is a cross between a brownie & a cookie. It's filled with chocolate like you've never had it before. Belgian dark chocolate, all crowned with sea salt flakes for a sweet & salty finish . It’s a dream for true chocolate lovers—and it doesn’t hold back.
"Boxes Curated Just For You"
​
​Meet the Six Signature Flavors:
-"The Carver"-Peanut Butter
- "The Legacy"-Chocolate Chip
-"The Heritage"-Butter Pecan
-"The Fannie"-Oatmeal Raisin
-"The Original'-White Chocolate Cranberry Almond
-"The Harriet"-Triple Chocolate
​
​This isn't your average snack pack.
Is it a sampler? No. Will it disappear in one setting? Probably.
Share them if you must, but, these cookies were created for indulgence.
​
Note: These cookies are NOT your average size cookies.
These cookies are 4-5 ounces each.
That's BIG!
ADD TO CART 1
Anchor 2
"Single Flavor Boxes You Select"
select Your Favorite flavor in a 6-Pk or 12-Pk
These cookies are not your regular size cookies.
These cookies are 4-5 ounces each!
That's BIG!
bottom of page